Trading Card Games

Buy and sell trading card games in Costa Rica.

A shoebox handed down from an older brother, with a few Charizards, a stack of Blue-Eyes and Magic lands nobody remembers buying, is how plenty of collections start. Trading card games change hands here new and pre-owned, from sealed boosters and preconstructed decks to the single card that finishes a set, along with the binders and sleeves that keep them. Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering and Yu-Gi-Oh! each have a page of their own, and newer games such as One Piece and Lorcana sit here. Ask where any foil-heavy lot was kept: a binder that spent years in a damp house in Limón rarely lies flat again.

How each card game decides what a card is worth:

the rules move prices as much as rarity does. Magic: The Gathering has been printed since 1993, and Commander, the casual 100-card format played around kitchen tables, keeps old cards useful long after they leave tournament play. Some early Magic cards sit on the Reserved List and will never be reprinted, so their prices only climb. In Yu-Gi-Oh!, Konami revises the Forbidden and Limited list several times a year: a banned card can lose most of its value overnight, and one that comes off the list jumps. Pokémon rotates its Standard format every year, so competitive cards drop when they rotate out while the collectable ones hold. Younger games such as the One Piece Card Game, Disney Lorcana and Star Wars: Unlimited are listed here. A reprint of a popular set can still pull down the price of its best cards, so pay for a recent chase card with that in mind.

The first deck, and why Yu-Gi-Oh! needs smaller sleeves:

a preconstructed deck is a cheaper way in than loose boosters. A Magic Commander precon plays straight out of the box, and Yu-Gi-Oh! players often buy the same structure deck three times, since three copies is the most a deck may hold and a triple set gives a solid core. Choose the game your friends or the nearest store’s weekly event already play. Size is the trap with accessories. Magic, Pokémon, Lorcana and One Piece cards share one standard size, but Yu-Gi-Oh! cards are smaller and need Japanese-size sleeves, so a box bought for one game will not suit the other. A side-loading binder that zips shut beats a ring binder, whose rings dent the cards in the column nearest the spine.

Curled foils from a humid closet in Limón:

foil cards bend because the shiny face does not take on moisture while the cardboard back does. A binder left for a few years in the damp air of Limón or Golfito comes back with its foils cupped towards the picture. Mild curl settles once the cards sit sleeved in a stable room, but a foil that curled hard can stay bent or crease, and a box stored damp often brings a musty smell and spots on the backs. Look at a stack of foils side on and smell the box; if you live near the coast, a sachet of silica gel in each deck box helps.

Bulk lots with the rares already pulled:

in a box of several thousand cards, nearly all the value sits in a few dozen. Before paying for a whole collection, ask to see those few front and back, and ask plainly whether anything has been taken out; boxes sold as bulk are often what is left after someone picked the rares. Check edges and corners for whitening and look for rubber-band dents. On any card that matters, use the game’s own check: the hologram stamp in the bottom-right corner of a Yu-Gi-Oh! card, or the rosette print pattern under a jeweller’s loupe on a Magic card.

Sorting an inherited shoebox before it goes up for sale:

split it by game first, because a Pokémon collector will not dig through Magic lands, and then by language. Set aside the foils, Magic cards with a gold or orange set symbol and anything with an old-style border, and look those up one by one. Photograph them front and back in daylight and say honestly whether the foils lie flat. The rest sells better as a counted lot per game than card by card. Someone buying a whole collection will want a table, good light and an hour to turn every binder page, so offer that rather than a handover through a car window.